Football: Towards a major change of rules in the United States?

scpa BERTRAND
09.08.17 19:25 Comment (s)
sports law firm in Paris France

The Miami FC club said it had appealed to the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) to force the US Soccer Federation (USSF) to introduce the system of promotion / relegation in its championships.

What about a climb / descent system between NASL and MLS?

The Miami FC Club won this season the title of champion of the NASL, considered by the USSF as a second-tier championship.


Despite this title, the Club is not promoted in Major League Soccer (MLS), this championship does not recognize the system of promotion and relegation common to most of the world football leagues.


This procedure before CAS was introduced jointly with the Club of Kingston Stockade ("4th division" club, National Premier Soccer League (NPSL)), in order to ask Fifa, Concafaf and USSF for their promotion in the championship. considered superior.

best sports lawyer

The position of the Miami FC Club

According to the Miami club, "The closed system for football used here in the United States is in violation of FIFA rules".

The Club indicates in its press release that it is simply asking the USSF, as a member of Fifa, to comply with FIFA rules.

He also recalls that, by not practicing promotion and relegation, the United States and Australia are the only two members of the 211 FIFA associations that break this basic rule.

Or book a video appointment online

The Regulations for the application of the FIFA Statutes

The two Applicant Clubs based their request, in particular, on Article 9 of the Implementing Regulationss Statutes FIFA which has:

"9 Principle of promotion and relegation

1. The authorization granted to a club to participate in a national championship is primarily based on strictly sporting results. A club can qualify for a national championship by remaining in the same division, being promoted or demoted at the end of a season. The authorization given to a club to participate in a national championship is primarily a function of results. strictly athletic. A club can qualify for a national championship by remaining in the same division, being promoted or demoted at the end of a season.

2. In addition to the sporting qualification, the participation of a club in a national championship may also depend on compliance with other criteria under a licensing procedure. In this context, the sports, infrastructure, administrative, legal and financial criteria must be preeminent. Decisions on the granting of licenses shall be subject to review by an appeal body within the member association. (...) ".

This same provision had been raised by Indian clubs in 2016 following the creation of the Indian Super League.

The USSF has not yet responded to the proceedings.

scpa BERTRAND